Independence and Homogeneity of Proportion Tests

Suppose one wishes to decide if two categorical variables are independent.

For example, suppose one compares the type of passenger (crew, 1st class, 2nd class, or 3rd class) on the doomed voyage of the Titanic and whether or not they lived or died in its sinking. Compiling the counts in each category given below, one might wonder if some types of passengers were more likely to live than others, or were these two variables independent of one another.

$$\begin{array}{l|cccc|c} & \textrm{Crew} & \textrm{1st Class} & \textrm{2nd Class} & \textrm{3rd Class} & \textrm{Total} \\\hline \textrm{Lived} & 212 & 202 & 118 & 178 & 710\\ \textrm{Died} & 673 & 123 & 167 & 528 & 1491\\\hline \textrm{Total} & 885 & 325 & 285 & 706 & 2201\\ \end{array}$$

The null hypothesis here is that the variables involved are independent, while the alternative hypothesis is that the variables are instead related.

The test statistic is again given by $$\chi^2 = \sum \frac{(O-E)^2}{E}$$ where the sum is taken over all possible combinations of categories (i.e., one for each entry in the table). $O$ represents an observed frequency (a single entry in the table), while $E$ is the expected frequency for the related observation given the null hypothesis.

Note that if $n$ is the sample size (i.e., the grand total for the related table) then $$\begin{array}{rcl} E &=& n \cdot P(\textrm{cell})\\ &=& n \cdot P(\textrm{row}) \cdot P(\textrm{column}) \quad \textrm{ assuming the variables are independent!}\\ &\doteq& n \cdot \frac{\textrm{(row total)}}{n} \cdot \frac{\textrm{(col total)}}{n}\\ &=& \frac{\textrm{(row total)} \textrm{(col total)}}{\textrm{grand total}} \end{array}$$

If the assumptions that all $E \ge 5$ are not met, this test should not be performed.

Provided the assumptions are met, the distribution associated with this test statistic should be a chi square distribution with degrees of freedom equal to the product: $$df = (\textrm{number of rows} - 1) \times (\textrm{number of columns} - 1)$$ As with the goodness-of-fit test, matching the expected frequencies better than anticipated will certainly not give us a reason to reject the null hypothesis, so this is a right-tailed test.

Test for Homogeneity of Proportions

Suppose one wished to test if more than two populations (or categories) were all found to be in the same proportions.

For example, suppose one wanted to know if the proportions of Democrats, Republicans, and Independents were the same for both men and women, and had collected the following data to this end. $$\begin{array}{l|ccc} & \textrm{Democrat} & \textrm{Republican} & \textrm{Independent}\\\hline \textrm{Male} & 36 & 45 & 24\\ \textrm{Female} & 48 & 33 & 16\\ \end{array}$$

The null hypothesis for this test is the statement that the proportions are the same between populations/categories.

Note, that in the example above, if and only if the variable of gender is independent of the variable of political party affiliation would our expectation for the proportions of Republicans, Democrats, and Independents be the same for men and women.

As the above observation suggests -- except for the way the null hypothesis is stated -- a test for the homogeneity of proportions is absolutely identical to a test for independence.